A Review of Antonio De Innocentis' "Guitar Recital" CD FIAM/001
Antonio de Innocentis is a new guitarist to me with this recording. The
registration date on the back of the CD cover is 1997. This means that the
CD has been floating around for about three years, yet it has not gotten
mainstream attention. This may be because
of limited resources on the part of the label company. A web search on his
name return only ONE reference!!! As my mother used to say, imperiously,
"This simply will not do!" To anyone who will listen I rant on and on about
this man's playing.
But enough of aimless enthusiasm, now for details.
Tracks 1-3 are of Sonatas of Domenico Scarlatti (specifically Kirkpatrick's
1, 208, and 209). In my experience only David Russell, the great Scottish
guitarist, plays Scarlatti with the same combination of technical assurance
(a very tricky thing with Scarlatti), musical and stylistic correctness, and
true harpsichord-like playing. This player's way with Scarlatti sounds very
much like the harpsichord playing of Rafael Puyana and Anthony Newman, two powerhouse players who are not afraid to play with both power and emotion.
Innocentis's two-string trills are blazing and crystal-clear. His control
of staccato and the stopping of notes at their exactly correct points is the
mark of a finely honed technique and a very meticulous musical mind.
One
exception, however, arrived when John Duarte pointed out to me that his only
criticism of this guitarist's playing here was in K.208. Duarte indicated
to me that the melodic line was "broken" by its jumps from one octave to
another. At first, given that I am accustomed to this sort of thing from
guitarists, I didn't even notice it. But Duarte is right. It's not that
this it is NEVER appropriate to break the melody's octave register, but K.
208 is such an extraordinarily lovely cantilena that the melody loses its
contour with the octave breaks. By the way, Scarlatti himself sometimes
broke octaves in melodies for dramatic effect. The playing here is gorgeous
as ever, but the arrangement does tend to "break up" the melodic line
unnecessarily. It's not really as extreme as I make it out to be, however.
It's not exactly like that marvelously spiky octave-eating melody in the
last movement of Prokofiev's Piano Concerto #2!
Listen to an MP3 sound file of Scarlatti's Sonata K1 allegro, as performed by De Innocentis. Please forgive the long download.
Years ago, in Los Angeles, a radio host named John Schneider (who hosted a
classical guitar program called "Soundboard") once said of David Russell's
playing of Bach, Scarlatti, and Haendel , "He doesn't just play this music,
he OWNS it!" Well, there is now a co-owner. Here is playing that is brim
full of power, musical confidence, and swagger. And by the way, swagger
(appropriately applied) is a quality in short supply in the classical music
world. It comes from a player's assurance that the music is fully
understood, within technical limits, and great fun to play. This last point
is probably Innocentis's greatest gift: he clearly LOVES playing the guitar
and its music. It shows. He can't help himself. He couldn't sound dull if
he tried. Not since I heard Julian Bream at UCLA for the very first time in
1969 have I been SO overwhelmed by a new player.
Tracks 4-6 are Sonatina (for Antonio de Innocentis) a new work by the
contemporary composer Giovanni Zaccari. This is a world-premiere recording.
The three movements are Allegro vivace, Calmo, and Allegro deciso alla
Tarantella. The first movement is an odd mix of different materials with
very little development. I would have preferred a bit more expansion of the
material here. The music seems to call for more than it gets in this first
movement. The second movement is quite the opposite. The subject is a
simple melody that is beautifully and spirally developed. The third
movement is something I would love to WATCH Innocentis play! It is played
at whirling-dervish speeds. The opening section gives way eventually to
more introspective music that is highly melodic and simple. It is not long,
however, before the opening speed and mood returns. When it does, it is
with an exquisite "mimicking" of the opening passages of
Castelnuovo-Tedesco's famous Tarantella. However, the pastiche doesn't last
long and we are coralled back into Zaccari's own music again. The opening
section's hair-raising chromatic scales and jaunty rhythms return and lead
directly to what I wish were a more satisfying close. This beautiful music
seems not so much to end as it does simply to stop.
Track 7 is a rare work from Castelnuovo-Tedesco, "Passacaglia, Op. 180,
Hommage to Roncalli". The passacaglia, as a compositional form, is
essentially a repeated bass with variational development in the upper lines
(though there are also areas wherein the repeated idea is in the middle and
upper ranges). Passacaglia is a difficult but extraordinarily beautiful
musical form. JS Bach wrote them to perfection, as did Benjamin Britten
(primarily as "catch your breath" sections in his operas) and others in the
20th century. Tedesco's Passacaglia is a masterwork of counterpoint, both
imitative and non-imitative. It also has that same muscular quality that
pervades his gorgeous Sonata ("alla Boccherini"). Innocentis holds the work
together beautifully. The moods from one variation to another are
appropriately and passionately expressed. I hope to hear others play this
difficult but very satisfying music.
Track 8 is Introduction and Caprice, of Giulio Regondi. As I have stated
before, I really don't care for most of the music written for the guitar in
the 19th century (except for Sor). This piece opens with some truly
charming music. After that, however, the music just pretty much leaves me
cold. Maybe I've heard too much Brahms and Schumann, and I expect too much
from others (who can't possibly stand up to such harsh comparison). And
it's not just that the forms that 19th-century guitarists wrote in were
simple. Beethoven wrote delightlful Bagatelles. They were simple, some
even rustic. But they were still, well, Beethoven! It's not the complexity
that makes the music, it's the ideas and how they are used. As parlor music
Regondi is fine, and there is nothing wrong with that. It is great fun for
students and some of it is VERY tough to play well (that makes it wonderful
study material). This music just seems to go on too long, but it does have
some VERY lovely moments. Also, Innocentis's playing is ravishing and he
does great service to this music.
Track 9 is "Tango en Skai" by Roland Dyens. This is one of the wildest
tangos I have ever heard. This one would do Piazzolla proud! In two
minutes and 22 seconds, Dyens simply sizzles. There is nothing more to say.
It is gorgeous music that is played with panache and more of that swagger
that I love about this man's playing.
Tracks 10 and 11 are Mallorca and Asturias, of Isaac Albeniz. Old warhorse
pieces in the guitar world, they run the risk of becoming ho-hum. In these
renditions, they are quite intoxicating. They are also played very much in
the spirit of how they are played on the piano (their original instrument,
after all). Mallorca is quietly lovely and stately, with its characteristic
long upward-moving melody. Asturias is played here in G minor. I still
can't get used to hearing it in any key but E minor! However, the playing,
again, is true to how you might hear the great Spanish pianists De Larrocha
or Soriano play it. The approach is VERY pianistic, and I just love it. It
is NOT what we have come to expect from guitarists, but it is ultimately
very convincing. Also, playing Asturias in E minor makes for lots of
resonating (and inappropriately sustained) repetitions of the note B --
especially the open second string. In the piano original, the repeated note
(D, in the original key of G minor) is played as a machine-gun staccato.
This presentation of the repeated notes is respected in this new
arrangement. The more I hear it in G minor on the guitar, the more I like
it.
Listen to Albeniz's Asturias, as performed by De Innocentis. This is a 5.9 meg download but this performance is unlike any other and important!
The CD closes with Giuliani's "Rossiniana, No. 6, Op. 124". Cadenzas here
are by our hero, Mr. de Innocentis. As almost 12 minutes of nonstop music I
don't really care too much for these pieces. This rendition succeeds more
because of the quite spectacular performance than because of the
compositional qualities of the music. Admittedly, there are many beautiful
passages (more to the credit of Rossini than to Giuliani, I fear). These
pieces work, when they do at all, because of superior performances such as this one. When Bream first brought these pieces to the attention of the
guitar world almost 30 years ago, he reworked them (much as Innocentis does
here, with his ravishing cadenzas). Make no mistake: the best thing about
this performance is the player, not the composer.
I don't know how you will find this CD, as it appears to be a local label in
Italy. Perhaps Larry Cooperman can arrange to have them available through
NewMillGuitar.com.
This player must become better known -- and fast! For such a talent to lie
fallow is truly an obscenity in a guitar world of so many well-connected
half-talents. Many of us are working hard to make his name better known.
When you see that he has finally been called to a music hall near you, GO!
As you leave that concert, I assure you that you will wonder why I was so
TEPID in my praise!
Unfortunately this CD is sold out and will not be re-released in the former incarnation. Look for a new release from Antonio De Innocentis featuring new works dedicated to him by John Duarte, Larry Cooperman and others.
Copyright 2006, new millennium Guitar Publishing Co., ALL RIGHTS RESERVED
|